Hmmm... that would explain why my experience playing in a group was so different from yours- usually your opinion is one of the few that I trust, so if you say something sucks, it usually does.
I've had fun playing the d20 version- it is newer, but I like a lot of the things about it. My group is all jedi, but we're fairly weak-sauce jedi, so the guy with the grenades is a big help. I'm thinking if my jedi gets killed off, I'm going to make a scoundrel smuggler. (Being severe lightside in a mostly darkside group has that pending issue of mortality.)
-kv